大数据时代编委会结构优化及作用提升
|
摘要
大数据时代,充足的数据资源使得定量评价和考核编委职能成为可能。基于来稿学科与编委学科比对分析,以及对编委学术活跃度和年龄结构的量化考核,优化编委会结构组成,并通过制度性建设,动态监管编委会职能发挥情况,可以显著提升编委的主观能动性。实践显示,经过结构优化和制度化建设后的《地球科学》和《Journal of Earth Science》编委会成员,既是作者,又是审稿专家,也是期刊的宣传组稿人员。实现了编辑、编委的优势互补,期刊组约稿能力的显著提高,促进了期刊的良性发展。
In the era of big data,it is possible to make quantitative evaluation and assessment of the functions of editorial committee based on the abundant data resources. After the comparative analysis between the disciplines of manuscripts submitted and those of the editorial committee,as well as the quantitative assessments of the academic activity and age structure of the editorial committee,the composition of the editorial committee structure can be optimized,and the subjective initiative of the editorial committee can be significantly improved through institutional construction and dynamic supervision. Practice results show that members of the editorial committee of Earth Science and Journal of Earth Science,after the structural optimization and institutional construction,are not only authors,but also reviewers and contributors of the journal publicity. The complementary advantages of editors and editorial committee make the acquisition of high-quality articles significantly increase,which promotes the benign development of periodicals.
In the era of big data,it is possible to make quantitative evaluation and assessment of the functions of editorial committee based on the abundant data resources. After the comparative analysis between the disciplines of manuscripts submitted and those of the editorial committee,as well as the quantitative assessments of the academic activity and age structure of the editorial committee,the composition of the editorial committee structure can be optimized,and the subjective initiative of the editorial committee can be significantly improved through institutional construction and dynamic supervision. Practice results show that members of the editorial committee of Earth Science and Journal of Earth Science,after the structural optimization and institutional construction,are not only authors,but also reviewers and contributors of the journal publicity. The complementary advantages of editors and editorial committee make the acquisition of high-quality articles significantly increase,which promotes the benign development of periodicals.
引文
[1]魏玉芳,薛宏交,林丽萍,等.浅淡科技期刊如何有效获取优质稿源[J].黄冈师范学院学报,2011,31(3):157
[2]陈浩元,杜文涛,颜帅,等.高校自然科学学报的发展与改革[EB/OL].(2005-11-29)[2018-12-02]. http:∥www. cujs. com
[3]陈浩元,郑进保,李兴昌,等.高校自然科学学报的功能及实现措施建议[J].编辑学报,2006,18(5):323
[4]刘俊婉.杰出科学家论文影响力的社会年龄分析[J].情报学报,2010,29(1):121
[5]陈朝晖,谢明子.如何正确发挥科技期刊编委会的作用[J].编辑学报,2007,19(3):205
[6]程林,莫愚,谢秋红,等.医学期刊编委会专家审稿组稿撰稿情况分析:以《中华烧伤杂志》为例[J].编辑学报,2018,30(5):496
[7]闫晓枫,韩纪富,张峰.发挥编委职责作用提高学报办刊质量[J].天津科技,2012,39(4):92
[8]张晗,李明敏,蔡斐.学术期刊编委会的建立与维护[J].编辑学报,2017,29(增刊2):36
[9]马超一,李禾.建立绩效考核制度促进编委会职能发挥[J].编辑学报,2017,29(1):52
[10]张凤新.科技期刊编辑在约稿环节的稿件质量控制与沟通技巧[J].科技与出版,2012(5):47
[11]叶金宝.大数据时代学术期刊的数字化探索[J].华中师范大学学报(人文社会科学版),2014,53(6):186
[2]陈浩元,杜文涛,颜帅,等.高校自然科学学报的发展与改革[EB/OL].(2005-11-29)[2018-12-02]. http:∥www. cujs. com
[3]陈浩元,郑进保,李兴昌,等.高校自然科学学报的功能及实现措施建议[J].编辑学报,2006,18(5):323
[4]刘俊婉.杰出科学家论文影响力的社会年龄分析[J].情报学报,2010,29(1):121
[5]陈朝晖,谢明子.如何正确发挥科技期刊编委会的作用[J].编辑学报,2007,19(3):205
[6]程林,莫愚,谢秋红,等.医学期刊编委会专家审稿组稿撰稿情况分析:以《中华烧伤杂志》为例[J].编辑学报,2018,30(5):496
[7]闫晓枫,韩纪富,张峰.发挥编委职责作用提高学报办刊质量[J].天津科技,2012,39(4):92
[8]张晗,李明敏,蔡斐.学术期刊编委会的建立与维护[J].编辑学报,2017,29(增刊2):36
[9]马超一,李禾.建立绩效考核制度促进编委会职能发挥[J].编辑学报,2017,29(1):52
[10]张凤新.科技期刊编辑在约稿环节的稿件质量控制与沟通技巧[J].科技与出版,2012(5):47
[11]叶金宝.大数据时代学术期刊的数字化探索[J].华中师范大学学报(人文社会科学版),2014,53(6):186