摘要
随着反家庭暴力法治进程的不断推进,随着人权保障工作的不断深化,我国特别是湖南省在防治家庭暴力法治道路中开拓创新,形成了自身特色。但是,基于多种因素的制约,我国的反家庭暴力法治工程尚未形成综合网络。本文试图以湖南省反家庭暴力法律规范文件剖析为视角,以湖南省反家庭暴力的司法实践为切入点,借鉴国外反家庭暴力丰富的理论和实践经验,初步探讨我国反家庭暴力的立法缺失,提出法律对策,进一步完善我国反家庭暴力法律网络。
引言部分简要说明了本文的选题原因、基本观点。希望本文能为弥补我国防治家庭暴力立法中的不足贡献自己的微薄之力,从而为我国防治家庭暴力寻找符合我国国情的实现途径。
第一部分,通过对家庭暴力内涵的比较,明确本文所指的家庭暴力；全面分析家庭暴力产生的思想、经济、政治、法律等原因,为后文探寻我国防治家庭暴力立法的不足之分析奠定基础,并为找寻法律对策提供支持。
第二部分,全面阐述了我国关于防治家庭暴力立法方面的现状,从民事、刑事、行政等实体法入手,结合程序法,找出我国目前立法中的不足,从而完善我国防治家庭暴力法律网络打下基础。
第三部分,以湖南省反家庭暴力法律规范文件剖析为视角,着重分析湖南省防治家庭暴力立法与实践中的创新,企图以湖南省防治家庭暴力的立法与实践经验作为试点,从而推向全国,推进防治家庭暴力法治进程。
第四部分,立足全国实情,结合湖南特色,借鉴域外法律和先进理论,从专门立法、民事、刑事、行政等实体法以及程序法和法律意识层面提出了相应的法律对策,试图构建一个综合性的科学的法律网络,为我国防治家庭暴力事业的前进贡献自己的绵薄之力。
结语部分,立足全文,笔者认识到了防治家庭暴力是一个综合系统工程,法治工程只是其中的一个子工程,只有真正落实各项法律,增强法治意识,防治家庭暴力工作才能颇有成效。
With the continuous progress of the process of law against domestic violence, with the development of human rights protection work, China, especially in Hunan, is on the pioneering and innovative way to the rule of law against domestic violence and forms their own characteristics. However, based on a variety of factors, China's anti-domestic violence law has not yet formed an integrated network engineering. This article tries to counter the analysis of the Hunan's documents about domestic violence laws and regulations as the starting point, the Hunan's judicial practice of anti-domestic violence as the breakthrough point,discusses the defects of China's anti-domestic violence legislation and puts forward some approaches, further perfecting the law against domestic violence.
Introduction section briefly describes the subject of this article, the basic idea. Hope this article to make up for anti-domestic violence legislation of insufficient contributions on their own meager strength, thus contributing to China's commitment to the prevention of domestic violence in line with China's national conditions of realization.
The first part, through the comparison of domestic violence, clear the meaning of the domestic violence in this paper. This part provides a comprehensive analysis of the cause of the domestic violence, such as ideology, economy, politics, law and etc, so as to explore the defects of current law and provide the basis for the future prevention of domestic violence, thus supporting the legal measures.
The second part comprehensively expounds China's legislation on the prevention and treatment status of domestic violence, from the perspective of the civil, criminal, administrative and other substantive law, combining with the procedural law, and identifys the shortcomings of current legislation, thus improving the network of prevention of domestic violence and laying the law basis.
The third part, based on the analysis of the violence laws and regulations in Hunan Province, focuses on the advantages of the anti-domestic violence legislation and the practice in Hunan Province, therefore attempting to push the experience of the Hunan Province to the whole nation and promoting the rule of law in the process of combating domestic violence.
The fourth part, based on the facts, combining with the features of the Hunan Province and the advanced theory of extraterritorial laws, from the perspective of the specific legislation, civil, criminal, administrative and other substantive law and procedural law and the legal consciousness puts forward the corresponding legal measures, trying to build a scientific comprehensive network of law and contributing to the progress of the cause of anti-domestic violence.
In conclusion, in concluding a full-text,the author recognizes that the prevention of domestic violence is a comprehensive systems engineering and the rule of law project is just one sub-project. Only the real implementation of various laws and the enhanceing awareness of the law, we can succed in combating domestic violence effectively.
引文
[1]巫昌帧,杨大文.防治家庭暴力研究[M].北京：群众出版社,2000.
[2]荣维毅,黄列.家庭暴力对策与干预[M].北京：中国社会科学出版社,2003.
[3]滕蔓.家庭暴力的内涵及其法律特征[A].载中国法学会.防治家庭暴力研究[M].北京：群众出版社,2001.
[4]李明舜.妇女权益法律保障研究[M].国家行政学院出版社,2003.116-117.
[5]陈明侠,夏吟兰,李明舜,薛宁兰.家庭暴力防治法基础性建构研究[M].中国社会科学出版社,2005.
[6]高风仙.家庭暴力防治法专论[M].台北：五南图书出版公司,2000.
[7]湖南省高级人民法院/湖南省妇女联合会联合编制.加强对家庭暴力受害妇女的司法保护之案件审理指导手册[M].2009年.
[8]北京大学法学院妇女法律研究与服务中心编.家庭暴力与法律援助-问题·思考·对策[M].中国社会科学出版社.
[9]毕玉谦.证明标准研究[M]//诉讼法论丛.第3卷.北京：法律出版社,1999.
[10]刘伯红.女性权利—聚焦《婚姻法》[M].北京.当代中国出版社.2002
[11]李洪翔.“家庭暴力”之法律概念解析[J].吉林大学社会科学学报,2007(4).
[12]孙丽.家庭暴力立法研究[J].西安电子科技大学学报(社会科学版),2004.(2)
[13]侯琦.对我国家庭暴力防治的法律思考[J].理论导刊,(8)
[14]王玲.反家庭暴力立法价值目标与制度完善[J].江西行政学院学报,2003(2)
[15]王雪娟.预防与制止家庭暴力的法律思考[J].辽宁公安司法管理干部学院学报2007(3)
[16]刘晓梅.英国反家庭暴力的立法、实践及其启示[J].法学杂志,2006.
[17]黄晓文.受虐妇女综合症专家证据在司法实践中的运用[J].法学杂志,2005(6)
[18]金眉.论反家庭暴力的立法缺失[J].法学家,2006(2)
[19]宋炳华.论家庭暴力防治中之民事保护令制度[J].中华女子学院报,2008(2)
[20]金眉.中国反家庭暴力立法评述.江苏警官学院学报[J].2009(1).
[21]黄斌.通过司法途径推动反对家庭暴力—中澳合作反对家庭暴力培训研讨会综述[J].妇女研究论丛,2009(4).
[22]赵颖.美国警察针对家庭暴力的：逮捕政策及干预模式研究[J].中国人民公安大学学报,2005 (1).
[23]马忠红.中美警察干预和处置家庭暴力案件比较研究[J].武汉公安干部学院学报,2010(1).
[24]王春光.澳洲反家庭暴力法律机制及其启示[J].法律适用.2004(10).
[25]周天枢.我国反家庭暴力的地方立法分析[J].世纪桥.2009(7).
[26]赵晓红.反家庭暴力的法律思考—论法律资源的整合与新法律体系的建构[J].北方论丛.2007(6)
[27]刘蕾.家庭暴力不再是“家务事” [J].法治与社会2002(9).
[28]钱泳宏.我国反家庭暴力应引人民事保护令制度[J].南通大学学报：社会科学版.2009(4).
①《中华人民共和国婚姻法》.中国法制出版社.2005
①李洪祥. “家庭暴力”之法律概念解析出处[J].吉林大学社会科学学报2007(4)
①刘伯红主编.女性权利—聚焦《婚姻法》[M].北京.当代中国出版社.2002,第98页
②刘伯红主编.女性权利—聚焦《婚姻法》[M].北京.当代中国出版社.2002,第165页
①周天枢.我国反家庭暴力的地方立法分析[J].世纪桥.2009(7)
②http://baike.baidu.com/view/2984815.htm
①刘蕾.家庭暴力不再是“家务事” [J].法治与社会2002(9).
②http://www.gov.cn/gzdt/2009-07/03/content_1356420.htm
①赵晓红.反家庭暴力的法律思考——论法律资源的整合与新法律体系的建构[J].北方论丛.2007(6)
①钱泳宏.我国反家庭暴力应引人民事保护令制度[J].南通大学学报：社会科学版.2009(4).
①毕玉谦.证明标准研究[M]//诉讼法论丛.第3卷.北京：法律出版社,]999.